Archive for March, 2009

Why Is Miles Still There?

I’m hoping they answer this minor plot issue, since right now it doesn’t make any sense based on what little we know about his character and motivations.

As far as we know, he was given at least 2 opportunities to leave the island in 1974 (on the sub the next day, and then 2 weeks later – assuming that offer was still on the table after those 2 weeks), and it’s reasonable to expect that unless something happened, he would have continued to have opportunities to leave over the course of the next three years which he apparently passed up.

Who knows how much he knows about the nature of the time travel stuff, but it would seem to me that it would be difficult for a guy like Miles to pass up the opportunity to head back to the mainland and become insanely wealthy by doing things like investing in the stock market with the future knowledge advantage that he would have.

Could it be that something happens before the two weeks are up that cuts off their option to leave? Or perhaps he knows enough about the nature of the timeline (or something else) to know that it just wouldn’t work out for him.

It will also be interesting to see whether he encounters (during that timeline) the people who many people believe to be his parents, or maybe even himself as a baby. If the scene we see with Faraday earlier in the season (in the tunnels under the Orchid) is any indication, it would certainly seem like the group is now present during that time.

Dharma Truce Origins

In the process of wondering how that truce came about, I started thinking of a bigger question – how did Dharma ever gain enough ground to even be able to negotiate a truce?

It’s believable now (1974-77 timeframe) that Dharma has enough people and resources to represent a threat that could hold the “others” at a standstill, but it seems like it would have taken them quite a bit of time to build up to that point, so why did Richard’s group allow that to happen?

The only explanation I can think of is that they were made aware (via “Jacob” or otherwise) that it was necessary for Dharma to be there, since all the stuff that has happened on the island since probably wouldn’t have happened, and if it “had to happen that way”, then it makes sense that they had to allow it.